last update: 10th December 2018
What we cover in this guide-> Quick navigation
It’s is quite interesting to compare the two biggest brands in carpet cleaning industry: Rug Doctor and Bissell. While Bissell has a wide array of carpet cleaners designed for both residential and commercial uses, Rug Doctor on the other hands has 4 models only.
Let’s compare side-by-side their direct competitive models to see which one is the better choice for your home.
- Rug Doctor Mighty Pro vs Bissell Big Green
- Rug Doctor Upright vs Bissell Proheat 2x
- Rug Doctor Portable vs Bissell Little Green 14259
- Rug Doctor Flexclean – Bissell does not have any model like this so far
Rug Doctor Mighty Pro vs Bissell Big Green
Entering any rental unit, you may see either Rug Doctor Mighty Pro or Bissell Big Green. This couple has become the best commercial carpet cleaning machines, not only now but for decades already. But do you know what is the pros and cons of each model?
Rug Doctor Mighty Pro and Bissell Big Green have a solid construction, huge water tanks to hold a lot of waters for a vast area cleaning. They do have powerful motors, great brush system and they are built by high-quality ABS plastic which can last for decades. Therefore, these models have a very long warranty time (5 years).
When dealing with highly soiled carpet, traffic carpet and thick carpet, these models are the best recommendation over the rest carpet cleaner models on the market. You might expect that they are also bulky and heavy therefore it is not ideal if you need to move upstairs /downstairs frequently.
The most important difference between Rug Doctor Mighty Pro and Bissell Big Green is how the brush system works. Bissell Big Green uses scrubbing brush system to scrub, loosen and remove the ground in dirt and stain, while Rug Doctor Mighty Pro uses an oscillating brush to vibrate and loosen the dirt. Therefore, Rug Doctor Mighty Pro will have a gentler action on the carpet fibers. Thanks to the gentling vibration, Rug Doctor Mighty Pro is the only carpet cleaner that can be used for high pile carpet cleaning (shag, berber…) as it won’t cause the carpet fiber to be damaged.
Another difference is about the motor rating. Bissell Big Green uses a motor of 6 amps and Rug Doctor uses a motor of 10 amps. The motor power somehow indirectly affects the suction power, however in the case of Bissell Big Green and Rug Doctor Mighty Pro, both models give equality in suction power.
Rug Doctor Deep carpet cleaner vs Bissell Proheat 2X
Rug Doctor Deep carpet cleaner is a scaled down model of the Rug Doctor Mighty, which is designed for home use and Bissell Proheat 2X series is the major carpet cleaning line for home use.
On the performance perspective, both of them can deliver a throughout cleaning on floor carpet, upholstery, pet stains, stair cleaning. They are priced at the same range (around $200 range), they are also very popular and have high ratings from thousands of users.
Even though they are designed for home use, each model caters a different cleaning needs.
Rug Doctor Deep carpet cleaner uses an oscillating brush system, higher capacity water tanks, big carpet-friendly wheels and a motor rating of 10 amps which are the best option if you have to clean thick carpet, medium pile carpet. This model is also certified by CRI with the gold label in performance. Therefore, the model is intended to give a deep, professional cleaning performance similar to Rug Doctor Mighty Pro (a more compact version). On the downside, Rug Doctor Deep carpet cleaner is still a heavy weight machine (37 lbs.).
Bissell Proheat 2X is a series of upright carpet cleaners including a lot of models, but for a general view, we take the case of Bissell Proheat 1986, the lasted model to compare. The special benefits of Bissell Proheat 2X carpet cleaner are that it has 2 cleaning modes: fast mode allows the carpet to dry in less than one hour and an express mode that will deep clean the carpet.
Bissell Proheat 2X is more flexible as it is lighter in weight (about 20 lbs), it has a low profile brush head (allow you to clean under furniture without removing it), a sprayer on the brush head (to tackle the stain), a pet tool that has a built-on dirty tank to capture the pet hair… With these specific details, Bissell Proheat 2X is a nice choice for busy home, home with pets and kids.
Rug Doctor Portable vs Bissell Little Green 14259
Bissell has a wide range of portable carpet cleaners which differs in design, cleaning capacity and intended uses. Some phenomenal portable models from Bissell are Bissell Spotclean Professional 3624, Bissell Little Green Proheat 14259, Bissell Spotbot Handsfree 33N8, Bissell Proheat 5207F and so on. Rug Doctor only has one model that is Rug Doctor Portable carpet cleaner.
When investigating into details, Bissell Little Green 14259 is comparable to Rug Doctor Portable, as they have one thing in common: the strongest suction power to remove stains on carpeted surfaces.
Further reading: Best portable carpet cleaner: reviews, rating and buying tips
Bissell Little Green Proheat 14259 uses a motor of 9 amps rating, and Rug Doctor uses a motor of 10 amps rating. Both models have equally powerful suction powers which are far more than any other on the markets. Both models have 2 water tanks design, a built-in sprayer to tackle the stains.
Bissell Little Green 14259 is lighter in weight when comparing with Rug Doctor Portable. In fact, it is just a half weight of the rival (9 lbs. Vs 20 lbs.) This is an advantage to give users more portability. On the other hand, the water tank capacity of Rug Doctor is bigger, meaning you can clean more stains, upholstery surfaces with less changing water trips.
To compensate for the weight, Rug Doctor Portable has 2 big carpet-friendly wheels which allow you to move around effortlessly without leaving visible marks on the carpet. It also has a collapsible handle for moving upstairs/ downstairs. Therefore, it is not as much heavy as you might think of.
A special feature of Rug Doctor Portable is that the brush is motorized, which gives up to 1200 moving times per minutes. When dealing with set-in stains, this unit works amazingly than any model.
For professional cleaning results in big areas, Rug Doctor Mighty Pro and Bissell Big Green are two best models. Rug Doctor Mighty Pro may have its advantage when dealing with frieze, shag.
For home cleaning uses, Rug Doctor Deep cleaner and Bissell Proheat 2X are very popular choices. They both have high ratings from thousand users. Bissell Proheat 2X is more compact, flexible and have a better ergonomic design. Rug Doctor Deep cleaner is certified for deep cleaning performance by CRI.
For stain cleaning, upholstery cleaning, Bissell Little Green 14259 and Rug Doctor Portable are two popular choices. Bissell Little Green 14259 is recommended when the weight is one of the most crucial standards for you, otherwise Rug Doctor Portable can offer the same value (with a bigger water tank, higher cleaning capacity).
You may love to read